Wednesday, 18 November 2026

The Secret in Their Eyes aka El Secreto de Sus Ojos (2009)

        Director and co-writer Juan José Campanella’s Oscar-winning (for 2010’s best foreign language film) Argentinian thriller is the latest to get the ultra-posh box set treatment from Second Sight. The limited edition will include the film on both 4K UHD and Blu-ray as well as a 120 page book with new writing on the film, six art cards and a rigid slipcase to keep it all in. The film will also be available in standard separate 4KUHD and Blu-ray editions.


Court investigator Benjamin Esposito (Ricardo Darin) has retired and turned his hand to novel writing, specifically one inspired by a case he was involved with 25 years ago which was never brought to a satisfactory conclusion. His determination to finish the book takes him to his former boss Irene (Soledad Villamil) and together they find themselves going over the facts.


The case itself involved the rape and murder of young school teacher Liliana Colotto (Carla Quevedo). Two men are almost immediately arrested for the crime but something looks wrong. Benjamin’s insistence on not letting the case go leads him down a dark and complex path which eventually threatens the life of both him and his friend Pablo Sandoval (Guillermo Francella).


Adapted (in part by the author himself) from Eduardo Sacheri’s novel of the same name, THE SECRET IN THEIR EYES starts slowly and intimately, and while that sense of observing characters (whom we come to genuinely care for) under a microscope never goes away, the plot in which they find themselves involved expands, but never to absurdist proportions. Campanella’s direction is restrained for the most part, such that when we get sequences of considerable flamboyance and panache worthy of Dario Argento they are all the more jaw-dropping. It’s an excellent piece of work and thoroughly deserving of being given this new release. 


Second Sight’s 4K transfer (in Dolby Vision) looks excellent. Don’t worry that the opening sequence looks as if it has patches of noise with poor resolution - it’s supposed to look that way, and the rest of the film positively glows. Extras on Second Sight’s disc include two commentary tracks - the first by academics Gizella Meneses (co-author of a book on Argentine Noir) and Dave Park, and the second by the director, which is in Spanish with subtitles. New featurette material consists of interviews with the director (31 minutes), producers Mariela Besuievsky and Gerardo Herrero (26 minutes), and composers Emilio Kauderer and Federico Jusid (19 minutes). Film critic Joe Lipsett provides a 17 minute video essay analysis of the film, especially relating to how the colour palette and visual style both contribute to the storytelling. Finally there’s a 44 minute archival making of.



Juan José Campanella’s THE SECRET IN THEIR EYES is out in 4K from Second Sight in a limited edition (UHD and Blu-ray plus book, etc) as well as standard UHD and Blu-ray editions, on Monday 23rd November 2026


No comments:

Post a Comment